|
Who's Side is Michael Robertson On?
Whose side is Michael Robertson actually on? You'd think that the man in charge of MP3.com would support digital music technology advances, but earlier this week Robertson surprised everyone by joining forces with the Recording Industry Association of America and the Motion Picture Association of America in asking U.S. District Judge Marilyn Hall Patel for a preliminary injunction to stop Napster's file sharing services.
MP3.com's recent settlements with Warner Music Group and BMG Entertainment are steps in showing the music world that MP3 technology is a tool that can greatly help artist promotion. Now that MP3.com is "legalizing" itself and playing by the rules, it looks like Mr. Robertson is making sure that everyone else has to do the same. "In the operation of our Website, we do not authorize unlawful or pirated MP3 files," states Robertson.
This backing of the RIAA on MP3.com's part may have had a direct result on Napster's representation at the MP3 Summit 2000. Liz Brooks of Napster did participate on the "Break on Through to the Other Side: Transitioning from the Traditional Music Industry into the Online Space" panel, but other Napster employees were sparse. With Napster Inc. getting so much media attention, you'd think they would really want to capitalize on it by making new connections with people and companies at the Summit.
A ruling on the injunction is expected in July 26th, 2000. If it is indeed granted, the actual task of shutting down Napster is another obstacle for Napster's foes. Since the traded files aren't stored in one specific place, like FTP servers, the MP3 files will still be on users' hard drives.
On a similar note, StopNapster.com (which is run by a rock band based out of Oakland, California) has recently named Michael Robertson "Executive of the Year." The site is even going as far as sending the MP3.com CEO a plaque honoring his work in defending intellectual property and intellectual freedom. (Runner up for the title goes to Bob Kohn, CEO of EMusic.com, for supporting a preliminary injunction against Napster's operations.)
User Comments
(These do not necessarily reflect the beliefs of this site)
|
doobybrain
|
Date: June 23, 2000 @ 10:13 PM
Robertson is a dork. well, thats what i think. |
|
Crack0rJack
|
Date: June 23, 2000 @ 10:26 PM
much agreed. Robertson = dork. i don't understand his stand on the matter at all. he should support his fellow Silicon Valley companies. |
|
Crack0rJack
|
Date: June 23, 2000 @ 10:26 PM
much agreed. Robertson = dork. i don't understand his stand on the matter at all. he should support his fellow Silicon Valley companies. |
|
pressf8
|
Date: June 23, 2000 @ 10:40 PM
screwMetallica.org disconnected their MP3 sponsorship today (friday). Got a statement up:
http://www.screwmetallica.org/nomp3com.htm
Brian
screwMetallica.org
|
|
jamuraa
|
Date: June 23, 2000 @ 11:01 PM
What's important to note is that Robertson is just pandering to the latest fad. It's now suddenly "cool" to be legal with everyone and to not get sued. The RIAA is suddenly willing to forget all it's beefs with MP3.com. Not more than 3 months ago, mp3.com was attacked by the RIAA because of their BEAM-IT shit. They were saying "screw the record companies" even then. Now he is pandering to them.
Jamuraa
emp3.com/puremp3.org
|
|
Heidi
|
Date: June 24, 2000 @ 4:40 AM
Another thing I noticed is that MP3.com's stock (MPPP) has really taken a nose dive this week, after it was doing so well with the recent settlements. The stock is down about $3.00 since Monday. |
|
Anonymous
|
Date: June 26, 2000 @ 3:22 AM
people like money
the RIAA make money by selling music
mp3.com make money by selling music
people on Napster get music for free
if the people on Napster can't get it for free, maybe they will buy it (and there-for the people selling music will make more)
I don't find it surprising at all that this guy is against Napster (wouldn't you... SERIOUSLY?)
what do you expect to do?? install Napster and give away all the mp3s he's trying to sell???
if anyone cares, I'm all for free music, but I'm also all for making money
people who sell stuff don't like to see the same stuff to be given away, and people who don't like to buy that stuff do like to see that stuff given away
...Hirudin
moral of the story: don't write stuff when you're 3/4 asleep |
|
Anonymous
|
Date: June 26, 2000 @ 3:24 AM
oops, it was suppose to say:
"...make more MONEY)"
"what do you expect HIM to do..." |
|
|